Why would someone want to turn wood into stone?
A stone building or home often conveyed a sense of lasting presence, wealth, and a connection to the many famous stone structures of antiquity that we so often try to emulate and incorporate into our architectural designs. So why not just build with stone in the first place?
The answer is usually economics — wood is a lot cheaper, easier to move and shape compared to stone — so if you could make your wooden home look like stone you’ll be keeping up with the Jones’ and not break the bank.
I just returned from a trip down to Washington D.C. where we also visited Mount Vernon — the home of George and Martha Washington with amazing views of the Potomac — and the most famous example of Feigned Rustication I am aware of.
What is Rustication?
Rustication is a term from the world of Masonry wherein the individual stones are squared off or beveled so as to accentuate the textured edges of each block. You can learn more about it on Wikipedia here. You can often see this feature on the lower and/or first levels of large masonry structures like banks and older stone office buildings. It provided a sense of grounding and provided a stark contrast to the smoother ashlar work on upper stories.
What is Feigned Rustication?
Feigned Rustication is the process of taking wood siding — carving/shaping it so that it looks like a series of rusticated stones, priming and painting it, and then when the paint is still wet covering it with fine sand so that the board takes on the color/shape/texture of stone.
Here is a close up view of this technique applied to the exterior siding and trim:
While not alchemy, this technique got the job done and from a distance it’s hard to tell the building is not made from stone until you get up close — and even then you have to know what you are looking at.
So while George and Martha Washington were generally quite wealthy during their time, they did make decisions that weighed materials vs. appearance vs. cost much the same way we do in our own homes today and stretched the dollar as much as they could. As you can see in the picture below, for secondary buildings they only applied this technique to the fronts of the buildings — around the corner you can see the siding reverts back to a nice beaded clapboard detail. You can also see some other more common faux finishes like artificial grain applied to some doors in the home — to make them look like expensive mahogany. This was a fairly common practice and not looked down upon the way some readers may be interpreting this.
Now that you’ve seen how we can transform wood into stone — were you fooled by the illusion? Are you going to work some similar alchemy on your own home’s exterior?
I highly recommend visiting Mount Vernon if you are in the Northern VA/Washington D.C. Area. You can find out more about this historic home, museum and grounds here.
In your travels if you find some other examples of Feigned Rustication, let me know here on the blog. (Another famous place with this treatment is Monticello also in Virgina)
7 thoughts on “Turning Wood Into Stone — Rustication at Mount Vernon”
The first time I went to Mount Vernon, I was just amazed at the “Stone” work on the mansion. This last visit was my husband’s first visit and he was studying it very closely. Great post!
Thank you. 🙂
Thanks for posting this article. What are the standard dimensions of a full board used for the siding? The boards look like they are maybe 2″ thick. What are the dimensions of the faux rusticated stone blocks? Are the boards rough sawn? Are the boards tongue-and-grooved, shiplapped, some other technique, or simply butt-jointed to the adjacent boards? How did GW protect against water intrusion under the siding? Were any wood preservatives other than paint and sand used, and how long did a board typically last before it needed replacement?
It was several years ago when I wrote up that blog post so I don’t recall the dimensions all that well but if I had to guess the planks used were likely 8/4 (aka 2″ thick that way there was still at least a full inch of wood behind the relief that simulated a mortar joint. I’m sure the lengths varried and likely ended in between simulated vertical mortar joints. And my guess is they were ship lapped boards and not likely full tongue and grove though I am guessing there as I did not see them disturbed. They were probably rough sawn and may well still be not he side facing the wall cavity. The outside likely was dress by hand plane and sawn, molded (via wooden molding plane) and/or carved to make the fake mortar joints in the wood.
Siding will last as long as it is maintained — meaning of the paint is maintained it can last indefinitely. When over the years things are left out to weather and decay exposing the wood it will quickly rot so it all depends. I hope this helps with your questions.
I would like to copy this technique on a new home I plan to build soon. I imagime 2 x 12’s milled smooth then molded would work. Thoughts??
Make sure you pick a wood species what weathers well. A standard SPF 2×12 will not weather all that well. Long pine, cedar or similar species — and the denser the rings and better the grain orientation the better it will last.
Excellent suggestions…I will bear this in mind when I consider availability and costs. I appreciate you taking the time to answer me.